Specialists dole out grades for New York Giants

What Chad Reuter needed to say:

The Giants ignored the historic quarterback run early on to seize Nabers, an explosive receiver with a recreation much like the workforce’s 2014 first-rounder, Odell Beckham Jr. We’ll see if sticking with Daniel Jones and Drew Lock as a substitute of taking one other QB was the right transfer. Nubin and Phillips had been truthful worth within the secondary, the place the workforce wanted extra expertise.

Johnson shall be a wonderful fourth-round choose if he can absolutely translate his athleticism to the sector. Tracy is an offensive weapon within the making, whether or not at working again or receiver. Muasau shall be a starter within the league regardless of being picked within the sixth.

What PFF needed to say:

Tracy is an effective athlete — he recorded a 4.48-second 40-yard sprint and 40-inch vertical bounce — and will add some explosiveness to a backfield led by Devin Singletary. Regardless of being a six-year participant in faculty, Tracy has just one season at working again, and he compelled 46 missed tackles on simply 114 carries in that 2023 season.

What USA TODAY needed to say:

The Daniel Jones haters is probably not mollified, however given the workforce was wed to him contractually this season regardless, GM Joe Schoen and HC Brian Daboll went in regards to the draft the appropriate means. First-round WR Malik Nabers (LSU) ought to be a field-flipping asset to Jones and/or whomever ultimately replaces him. Third-round Kentucky CB Dru Phillips will compete towards anyone. Some second-round maneuvering over the previous few months netted extremely regarded Minnesota S Tyler Nubin and former Panthers move rusher Brian Burns, who’s already signed an extension and now bookends Kayvon Thibodeaux. Stable-plus.

What the Washington Put up needed to say:

The Giants opted to assist Daniel Jones, because the QB returns from his torn ACL in his proper knee, reasonably than looking for his eventual successor. They stayed put at No. 6 total, handed up the obtainable quarterbacks and selected WR Malik Nabers. He might be a star — if the Giants have a QB able to getting him the ball. They added the draft’s top-rated security, Tyler Nubin, in the course of the second spherical.

What The Ringer needed to say:

THE GIANTS DECIDED TO HITCH THEIR WAGON TO DANIEL JONES (AND/OR DREW LOCK) FOR ANOTHER YEAR, eschewing the chance to draft a quarterback at no. 6 to as a substitute take electrical receiver Malik Nabers. The previous LSU move catcher is pace personified, giving the workforce a much-needed no. 1 receiver to construct the offense round. The workforce then circled on Day 2 and bolstered its secondary, grabbing my top-ranked security Tyler Nubin within the second spherical earlier than including feisty cornerback Andru Phillips within the third. Each may begin from the get-go. Within the fourth spherical, New York chosen a extremely athletic tight finish in Theo Johnson, who’s uncooked however nicely constructed and versatile and gives depth if and when Darren Waller retires. I preferred the Tyrone Tracy addition within the fifth spherical, too—the previous receiver-turned-running again who provides an explosive ingredient to the workforce’s working backs group and offers the workforce a possible change-of-pace and pass-catching choice on third downs.

What CBS Sports activities needed to say:

The Giants’ theme was pinpointing big-time athletes on this class. Nabers was my WR1, so advantageous begin there. Phillips was some of the spectacular plant-and-drive nook within the class, and Johnson was probably the most athletic tight finish along with his finest soccer in entrance of him. 

Tracy can threaten Devin Singletary for the RB1 and, if he can shore up his tackling, Muasau’s play-recognition expertise are spectacular. He beats blockers with relative ease, too. 

What Sports activities Illustrated needed to say:

The hope is that Nabers is all the things he’s been billed to be. The comparisons for him pre-draft had been extremely glowing, however the Giants have been right here earlier than. A star receiver out of LSU desires the ball and an underperforming quarterback is struggling to get it to him. If Nabers lifts Daniel Jones into perpetual above-averageness, then this was well worth the main swing. It’s additionally good to proceed rebuilding this secondary post-Wink Martindale because the Giants put together for one thing rather less guerilla model. 

What the Related Press needed to say:

WR Malik Nabers (6) fills a serious void. Boosted the secondary on Day 2 with S Tyler Nubin (47) and CB Andru Phillips (70). RB Tyrone Tracy Jr. is uncooked however has potential.

What Mel Kiper Jr. needed to say:

The Giants had been on the clock at No. 6 total Thursday evening, confronted with an enchanting determination: Would they take quarterback J.J. McCarthy — which might have been an admission that they remorse the Daniel Jones extension from the 2023 offseason — or would they get a real No. 1 wideout for Jones in both Rome Odunze or Malik Nabers? They may begin recent below middle or they might give Jones one other 12 months with the playmaker he has by no means had.

Finally, I feel they made the appropriate name, prioritizing a pass-catcher in Nabers (6), who is electrical with the ball in his fingers. Jones had a disappointing begin to final season after which tore his ACL, however he confirmed his expertise in 2022, when New York made a shocking run to the playoffs. Now he’s going to have another 12 months to show he’s the man, or the franchise will transfer on in 2025.

I’d have taken a number of different safeties forward of Tyler Nubin (47) in Spherical 2, however you may’t deny his playmaking potential; he had 13 profession interceptions for the Golden Gophers. Dru Phillips (70) is a late riser who performed lots of slot protection snaps in his profession. With Darren Waller’s future up within the air, I preferred the choose of Theo Johnson (107) early on Day 3. He’s my fourth-ranked tight finish within the class.

This can be a small class, however all 4 of the Giants’ prime choices ought to have important roles this season. Nabers may find yourself being the most-targeted participant on the workforce.

What Doug Farrar needed to say:

When your quarterbacks are Daniel Jones and Drew Lock, does it matter what else you do within the draft? We’re about to seek out out. A minimum of the Giants gave their middling quarterbacks the perfect receiver on this class in Malik Nabers, who’s form of a quicker Steve Smith in his enjoying character. Penn State tight finish Theo Johnson can even assist. And whereas I’m not as excessive on Kentucky cornerback Andru Phillips are, he’s a reliable slot defender. Getting Tyler Nubin within the second spherical ought to ease the ache of dropping Xavier McKinney in free company.

The sleeper right here — and one in all my favourite working backs on this class — is Tyrone Tracy Jr., the previous Iowa receiver who could have had probably the most insane run within the NCAA final season. The Giants bought lots of expertise on this draft, however once more… how a lot will it matter?