Today in Sports
  • Home
  • Featured News
  • Football
  • Basketball
  • Baseball
  • More
    • Rugby
    • Golf
    • Boxing
    • Soccer
    • NBA
    • Racing
    • Cricket
  • DMCA
  • Disclaimer
  • Cookie Privacy Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Contact us
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Featured News
  • Football
  • Basketball
  • Baseball
  • More
    • Rugby
    • Golf
    • Boxing
    • Soccer
    • NBA
    • Racing
    • Cricket
No Result
View All Result
Today in Sports
No Result
View All Result

Is the FIA proper to make ten seconds the brand new normal for penalties? · RaceFans

March 17, 2024
in Racing
0
Home Racing
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


Penalties in Formulation 1 have been a contentious space ever since stewards started to turn into way more energetic in grands prix across the notorious 2008 season.

You might also like

What are they and how many does each F1 driver have?

Spanish Grand Prix: Post Race press conference

NextGP – F1 Countdown & Calendar App Now on iOS (Android coming soon)

Thirty years in the past, penalties have been a rarity. When a driver was penalised for an infraction, it was typically with a full ten-second stop-and-go penalty.

In current instances, time penalties have turn into the usual punishment for infractions. Throughout races, stewards will subject a time penalty {that a} driver should serve at their subsequent pit cease earlier than any work will be carried out on the automobile, or it will likely be added to their ending time on the finish of the race if they don’t make one other pit cease.

The preferred penalty for racing associated infractions – akin to inflicting a collision or for leaving the monitor and gaining an enduring benefit – has been 5 seconds. However there have been instances when this punishment has not appeared to suit the crime.

When Sergio Perez shoved Alexander Albon out of tenth place late in final 12 months’s Singapore Grand Prix, he was handed a 5 second penalty for being “predominantly accountable” for the transfer. Regardless of that, he completed the race in eighth, simply over ten seconds forward of Liam Lawson, whereas Albon missed the factors in eleventh. That meant that Perez gained extra from his transfer on Albon than he misplaced from his eventual penalty.

The FIA appears to have taken heed of incidents like this. Final weekend, Kevin Magnussen was penalised twice within the race in Jeddah – first for inflicting a collision with Albon into flip 4, the second for leaving the monitor and gaining a bonus when passing Yuki Tsunoda on the identical nook.

Advert | Change into a RaceFans supporter and go ad-free

However what was most attention-grabbing was that Magnussen acquired a ten second time penalty for each – not 5. That left him with a complete of 20 seconds of penalties, which successfully ended his race and made Haas sacrifice his race to profit workforce mate Kevin Magnussen.

Perez received 5 seconds for this conflict in 2023

This may occasionally have appeared extraordinary, however throughout Formulation 2 and F3’s opening rounds in current weeks, there have been a number of ten second penalties for drivers akin to Amaury Cordeel, Gabriel Bortoleto and Joshua Duerksen for both inflicting collisions or making off-track passes, with Cian Shields additionally getting ten seconds for clasing with Josh Dufek at flip one in Bahrain.

Of their choice doc for Magnussen’s penalty for clashing with Albon, the stewards acknowledged that their ten second penalty was “consistent with the revisions made to the 2024 penalty tips.” The governing physique has listened to suggestions from drivers and groups from final season and agreed to extend the usual penalty for these incidents from 5 to 10 seconds so as to create a stronger deterrant for drivers.

However is a harsher normal penalty the appropriate method for the game to be taking?

For

Over the size of a grand prix, which regularly lasts for round 90 minutes and sees automobiles repeatedly separated by 20 or so seconds, a penalty of simply 5 seconds is extraordinarily minor.

Rising the requirements penalty to 10 seconds will assist to cut back cases of drivers committing ‘fouls’ on monitor however ending up with a web profit from it.

When it’s in drivers’ strategic pursuits to interrupt the principles because the penalty is not going to drawback them, one thing wants to alter.

In opposition to

All drivers, groups and followers have been calling for over a few years in the case of stewarding in Formulation 1 is consistency.

By altering the usual penalty, drivers this season might be handled twice as harshly for incidents that happen throughout a race than they have been final season.

Not solely is that inconsistent, is it actually honest? Particularly within the age the place purple flags are used way more liberally than earlier eras, a late penalty might simply drop a driver from a podium to outdoors the factors.

Advert | Change into a RaceFans supporter and go ad-free

I say

That is an encouraging transfer by the FIA for 2 most important causes. The primary is that we have now seen far too many incidents in current seasons the place drivers have opted to make unlawful overtakes and never hand the positions again figuring out that they’ll really lose extra time letting a rival by and attempting to cross them once more than if they simply take the penalty.

Niels Wittich, Spa-Francorchamps, 2022
It’s good race management is listening to drivers

For the supposed ‘pinnacle of motorsport’, it’s completely fallacious that any driver can be incentivised to overhaul a rival outdoors of monitor limits as a result of it will be higher to take action than to aim a authorized cross within the first place. Even worse, Perez’s measly penalty for knocking Albon out of the factors in Singapore ought to have left all followers of the game with a foul style of their mouths.

The FIA’s change in method, making the penalty for such infringements harsher by default – however selected a case-by-case foundation – ought to go some technique to eradicating that aspect from the racing.

The second cause this can be a constructive growth is that that is an instance of the FIA listening to drivers and taking motion based mostly on direct suggestions from the opponents themselves. Whereas the FIA are there to make guidelines to make sure protected and honest racing and to not give the drivers what they need, that is clearly a case of constructive dialogue between the rule makers and the rule breakers. Hopefully this type of suggestions loop will proceed into the longer term.

You say

Is the FIA proper to extend its normal time penalty in Formulation 1 from 5 to 10 seconds? Have your say on this week’s ballot.

Do you agree with the rise of the usual time penalty in F1 from 5 to 10 seconds?

No opinion (0%)Strongly disagree (7%)Barely disagree (4%)Neither agree nor disagree (9%)Barely agree (23%)Strongly agree (57%)

Complete Voters: 74

Loading ... Loading …

A RaceFans account is required so as to vote. In the event you should not have one, register an account right here or learn extra about registering right here. When this ballot is closed the outcome might be displayed as an alternative of the voting kind.

Advert | Change into a RaceFans supporter and go ad-free

Debates and polls

Browse all debates and polls



Source link

Tags: FIApenaltiesRaceFanssecondsstandardten
Share30Tweet19

Recommended For You

What are they and how many does each F1 driver have?

by TODAY IN SPORTS
June 2, 2025
0
What are they and how many does each F1 driver have?

During a Formula 1 race, stewards can hand out all manner of punishments to drivers that breach the regulations. Time penalties, fines and reprimands are often dished out...

Read more

Spanish Grand Prix: Post Race press conference

by TODAY IN SPORTS
June 1, 2025
0
Spanish Grand Prix: Post Race press conference

Track Interviews- Conducted by David Coulthard & Terry Crews(DC): Oscar Piastri, the end to a perfect weekend. That wasn't as easy as I was expecting for you guys...

Read more

NextGP – F1 Countdown & Calendar App Now on iOS (Android coming soon)

by TODAY IN SPORTS
June 1, 2025
0
NextGP – F1 Countdown & Calendar App Now on iOS (Android coming soon)

Hi everyone, I just released NextGP, a simple app for Formula 1 fans to track upcoming races and sessions. It includes: • Full F1 2025 calendar with session...

Read more

Hard Work Pays Off For Chase Burrow In CARS Tour

by TODAY IN SPORTS
June 1, 2025
0
Hard Work Pays Off For Chase Burrow In CARS Tour

HAMPTON, Va. — Since embarking on his first full-time zMAX CARS Tour season back in 2022, Chase Burrow has always shown potential to win races. With five top...

Read more

Why McLaren is surprised by Red Bull gap at F1 Spanish GP, but not by front wing outcome

by TODAY IN SPORTS
June 1, 2025
0
Why McLaren is surprised by Red Bull gap at F1 Spanish GP, but not by front wing outcome

McLaren Formula 1 team principal Andrea Stella has explained why he expected Red Bull to be closer in qualifying for the Spanish Grand Prix as the FIA's front...

Read more
Next Post
Nick Nurse ‘Fairly Assured’ Joel Embiid Will Return Earlier than Playoffs

Nick Nurse 'Fairly Assured' Joel Embiid Will Return Earlier than Playoffs

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related News

Manchester United may make ‘severe bid’ for in-demand supervisor, following disappointing season beneath Erik ten Hag: report

Manchester United may make ‘severe bid’ for in-demand supervisor, following disappointing season beneath Erik ten Hag: report

May 21, 2024
Wallaroos Head Coach Jo Yapp to return to England after World Cup

Wallaroos Head Coach Jo Yapp to return to England after World Cup

May 26, 2025
Arne Slot says 1 Liverpool youngster has earned place in first-team squad – Liverpool FC

Arne Slot says 1 Liverpool youngster has earned place in first-team squad – Liverpool FC

January 29, 2025

Browse by Category

  • Athletics
  • Baseball
  • Basketball
  • Boxing
  • Cricket
  • Football
  • Golf
  • MMA
  • NBA
  • NFL
  • Racing
  • Rugby
  • Soccer
  • Tennis
Today in Sports

Get the Latest Sports News and Updates on TodayInSports.net. Soccer News, Basketball News, Baseball News, Golf News, Boxing News and More!

CATEGORIES

  • Athletics
  • Baseball
  • Basketball
  • Boxing
  • Cricket
  • Football
  • Golf
  • MMA
  • NBA
  • NFL
  • Racing
  • Rugby
  • Soccer
  • Tennis

Recent News

  • Liverpool winger Ben Doak is being targeted by rivals Everton
  • Chelsea enter talks to sign Man United target Jamie Gittens – Man United News And Transfer News
  • Titans’ Cam Ward already earning respect from vets, O-line
  • Contact us
  • Cookie Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • DMCA
  • Get the Latest Sports News and Updates on TodayInSports.net.
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

Copyright © 2024 Today in Sports.
Today in Sports is not responsible for the content of external sites.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Featured News
  • Football
  • Basketball
  • Baseball
  • More
    • Rugby
    • Golf
    • Boxing
    • Soccer
    • NBA
    • Racing
    • Cricket

Copyright © 2024 Today in Sports.
Today in Sports is not responsible for the content of external sites.