I used to be chatting with a colleague the opposite day (one of many few who will nonetheless converse with me!) and we have been speaking concerning the ethical, moral, financial disaster introduced on by the Saudi Arabian takeover of boxing.
Most of us “within the know” can see the perils and pitfalls of signing over full management to the whims of the Saudi Royal Household and their Royal Courtroom (Particularly, Chairman of Saudi Arabia’s Normal Leisure Authority, Turki Alalshikh). So, actually, these “within the know” who nonetheless select to take the cash to assist and abet Saudi management are giving a big “fuck you” to the sports activities they declare to like and the athletes they declare to respect.
However is it severely any shock in anyway that boxing individuals on any level– promoters, boxers, managers, and even media– are solely about “getting that bag?”
It’s clearly why the boxers are like that. They’ve only a restricted period of time to earn a lifetime’s earnings. For promoters and managers, the cash seize is a “cash-out now” enterprise determination. Media selecting to promote out, nicely, that’s simply them being who they’ve proven themselves to be, being piggies on the Saudi trough like they’ve been piggies at promoters’ troughs.
However I digress…
The purpose my colleague made was that we– the balls-intact, non-whorish few left– must discover a higher approach to clarify why promoting the game over to the Saudis is like leasing out your lady’s boarding faculty to Jeffrey Epstein.
I’m normally a “determine this shit out by yourself whereas I smash heads with a baseball bat” form of man, however I’ll pull again a bit this week and attempt to make my case why all of that is only a actually, actually unhealthy and dangerous thought.
A Monopoly is Unhealthy
Make no mistake about it, what Turki Alalshikh and the Saudis try to do is create a boxing monopoly the place they personal Boardwalk, Park Place, all of the railroads, all of the utilities, and the entire fancy properties to the fitting of St. James Place.
In a surprisingly brief time period, they’ve been capable of purchase full compliance from promoters, administration, sanctioning our bodies, broadcasters, and media.
As I wrote within the digital pages of the reborn Boxing Tribune:
“Alalshikh has leveraged himself right into a place of supreme energy within the sport, with agency management of a still-growing boxing endeavor that oversees promotion, matchmaking, administration, occasion internet hosting, broadcasting, sanctioning, and now media– with each tentacle of that multi-armed beast referring again to him and executed in keeping with his whims, even when technically managed by intermediaries.”
As for why monopolies are bad– particularly so in boxing?
That’s a tough argument to make to these followers watching among the huge fights being signed within the current tense. It will get even harder when bought-off media loudly sings the praises of “His Excellency” Turki Alalshikh for making “the fights we wish to see,” particularly when juxtaposed in opposition to a boxing enterprise dynamic that’s (rightly) seen as muddled and inefficient in delivering a constant high quality product to followers.
It certain does appear that having all management beneath one keffiyeh would make for a greater product.
“Appear” can be the operable phrase there. Score notion versus actuality, although, would inform you that the Saudi boxing run hasn’t actually made any fights “we wish to see” that wouldn’t/couldn’t have been made by boxing’s common bossmen beneath regular enterprise situations. The one distinction in all of that is that the Saudis subsidizing these fights makes for extra money within the promoters’ pockets. So, yeah, the promoters are tickled pink they usually’re singing the praises of these making all of them this more money. Media then picks up on that reward and helps promote the fandom on the narrative.
In most monopolies, the patron does see some brief time period profit to the collusion. In the long run, nevertheless, such conditions are by no means good for the patron or labor (on this case, boxers) as a result of, as soon as somebody has whole energy over an trade, in addition they have whole energy over setting costs, setting high quality management, paying labor, establishing working situations, and so forth. And energy doesn’t search energy to wield it magnanimously for the advantage of all.
How Fighters Will Be Harm
A windfall for fighters now will doubtless be a bust later as they discover themselves negotiating open market offers in very a lot a closed market the place, in actuality, one entity controls purse strings for all events concerned in talks.
That may be an unlawful enterprise setup in any trade in any open-market, industrialized nation. With all boxing dealings popping out of Saudi Arabia, although, that is exterior of any Western jurisdiction.
The Saudis aren’t on this to construct boxing to common glory or as a result of Turki simply actually, actually loves the game. They’re on this for their very own profit and if their boxing efforts comply with their efforts in different sporting initiatives (soccer, golf) their purpose is to personal the game, deliver it residence as their very own plaything, and use it as a instrument to counterpoint their nation in any variety of methods.
The bossmen controlling boxing have performed a horrible job in delivering fights to followers in a well timed style, however the one approach to repair that for the long-term good of the game is thru the free market.
A monopoly on boxing will see many fighters within the right here and now profit from greater purses as they’re lured into compliance with the takeover. Then, fighters will see these purses steadily drop as caps are put in place to manage earnings. No one will be capable to say no as a result of there can be nowhere else to go for an enormous battle and/or photographs at sure titles.
When it comes to the game, itself, there are critical doubts as as to if Turki and the Saudis– with management over all the pieces, zero accountability, and a need to drive plans into fruition– would select to, more-than-occasionally, tip the scales in favor of 1 fighter or one other. Corruption is actual in boxing, however the Saudi-run boxing mannequin would invite and virtually demand rotten dealings.
Of their brief time on the near-top, we’ve already seen drug testing conveniently forgotten for a selected battle, Turki circumventing legality by arranging for fights exterior of the fighter’s legally binding promotional contract, and rumored intervention in free brokers signing to Saudi-friendly promoters. We’ve additionally seen a surly and aggressively dismissive angle from the Saudi figurehead when fighters and different boxing-related entities aren’t correctly deferential to him and to his concepts.
How Followers Will Be Harm
I don’t care which “huge” fights they’re getting, there’s no means that the notoriously fickle American boxing fan might be joyful to have most of the greatest fights happen abroad, at odd afternoon occasions, in a sterile setting, on exhibits which are paced like an extended afternoon on the DMV. Frankly, the Saudi exhibits are likely to suck and lots of followers, whether or not they admit it or not, both can’t or gained’t sit by way of these playing cards and their foolish musical acts to catch greater than a battle or two of their selecting. Most, additionally, usually are not paying to sift by way of the afternoon-long affair as pay-per-view buys have been completely feeble for these exhibits.
Alalshikh’s guarantees of lowered pay-per-view costs have to this point turned out to be suspect because the proposed $20 cap will already transfer as much as $40 (for Usyk-Fury 2), plus be tied right into a month-to-month $20 subscription to his most popular broadcast platform, DAZN. Anticipate additional “changes” as his energy will increase and his exhibits proceed to lose cash.
The siphoning off of expertise and cash has additionally weakened the US boxing scene and seemingly pulled the fireplace and resolve from US-based promoters. I pointed this out beforehand, however in an 8-month span (From June 2024 to February 2025), Jake Paul vs. Mike Tyson will go down as the one main card on US soil by an American promoter. That’s ridiculous and a harbinger of issues to return in a boxing world more and more wrangled right into a Saudi corral.
British boxing followers, in the meantime, have actually witnessed their whole scene co-opted by the Saudis as promoters Frank Warren, Eddie Hearn, and Ben Shalom rushed to grovel on the toes of “His Excellency.” In a nauseatingly fast time period, the keepers of UK boxing rolled over and offered away their self-determination.
Saudi Instability, Lack of Lengthy-term Dedication To Boxing
By it’s very nature, a monarchy like Saudi Arabia is constructed across the whims of 1 man. On this case, it’s Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, who seized full energy of the “Kingdom” in 2017, with the heavy-handed assist of Turki Alalshikh.
I’ve joked about this earlier than, however the one-man rule actually does imply that everyone beneath the Crown Prince may just about be one cross phrase or soiled look away from being discovered chopped up in a duffel bag someplace. In all seriousness, although, there’s a wildly elevated instability in a nation the place one man calls each shot and may change programs at any time when he likes. It additionally should be famous that bin Salman has ruffled loads of feathers and has pissed loads of highly effective Saudis off– together with, reportedly, different members of the Royal Household– in his rise to absolute energy.
When it comes to enterprise maneuverings, methods and spending practices of the Saudi Public Funding Fund (PIF) have fluctuated over time. The Monetary Instances lately reported on the Saudis’ restructured funding technique to maneuver away from investing in overseas companies and deal with efforts that extra straight affect their home scene.
For boxing, that might imply continued spending on occasions in Saudi Arabia with much less spending on playing cards overseas.
The Saudi exhibits, to this point, have been money-losers. Does anybody count on them to proceed to shovel cash into fights indefinitely, perpetually working within the purple, simply because Turki “loves” boxing?
Alalshikh, for all his bluster and massive guarantees, has not spoken a lot about the way forward for the game past the highest fighters proper now. His boxing league thought, which proposes to match the highest versus the highest in an expansive loop of matchups, is conspicuously obscure about how stars of tomorrow will probably be constructed when the entire focus and the entire cash is invested in huge, showy playing cards that includes stars of at this time. Some would say that’s as a result of his solely plan for boxing, proper now, is centered round seizing management of it. Past that, there’s not a lot of a plan.
Sportswashing and the Moral Implications
Sadly, for followers, media, and boxing businessmen, that is most likely the bottom issue on the totem pole checklist of considerations.
Saudi Arabia is a persistent violator of human rights and has earned its popularity as a murderous monarchy. They’re tying themselves to sports activities and leisure in an try to bury their popularity and “sportswash” the blood from their palms.
They’ve beheaded individuals decided to be criminals by their kangaroo courts. They’ve imprisoned and tortured dissidents, typically for as little as a considerably destructive Tweet concerning the Royal Household. They’ve “purged” non-public residents of wealth and property. They’ve imprisoned and murdered journalists, infamously Washington Submit reporter Jamal Khashoggi. And the nastiness continues to be ongoing as lights are shined on their sporting acquisitions.
The willingness of boxing media, particularly, to assist within the sportswashing has been notably off-putting (though not stunning) because the now Turki-owned Ring Journal joins Yahoo’s Uncrowned, and DAZN-affiliated reporters (in addition to some rumored different media voices) to promote a pro-Saudi narrative and drown out voices of dissent. Hell, the Boxing Writers Affiliation of America (BWAA), which describes itself as a safeguard for “the best skilled and moral requirements in boxing journalism” has additionally rushed to promote itself off as each the sitting President and Vice President appear set to work for Alalshikh and the Saudis.
Conclusion
Does any of this matter to the common fan simply searching for fights to observe? In all probability not. But it surely ought to. As a result of the issues they’re overlooking at this time will certainly have an effect on the standard of the product they look ahead to, possibly, many years to return.
It’s not honest for followers to must be so aware of their choices as shoppers, however boxing is a special form of enterprise. Already missing safeguards and voices that demand honest play and accountability, boxing is a hustler’s paradise. A Saudi-run sport would function solely with out guardrails. Exterior of any Western jurisdiction and missing any free press to not less than demand a level of accountability, actual, lasting injury might be performed to an already-damaged sport. To an extent, this might be a kill shot of kinds for a sport that by no means may fairly kill itself off regardless of many years of suicidal enterprise practices.
I’m beneath no phantasm that this clarification will even attain all that many followers because the bought-off institution media will be certain that voices of dissent are buried. There’s positively a little bit of futility in me sitting right here, with little-to-no platform, capturing spitballs at battleships. However, as I additionally defined to my colleague, “futile” is kinda my factor.
Bought one thing for Magno? Ship it right here: paulmagno@theboxingtribune.com
