It was speculated to be a 12 months of celebration for the New York Giants however has as an alternative become a nightmare of historic proportions.
The crew’s a hundredth anniversary obtained off to a nasty begin with “Arduous Knocks: Offseason with the New York Giants,” which highlighted their failures to land a brand new quarterback whereas permitting working again Saquon Barkley to affix the Philadelphia Eagles.
Quick ahead to the current time and the Giants are 2-12, have misplaced a franchise-record 9 straight video games, and are 0-8 at dwelling with one recreation remaining. Ought to they lose their MetLife Stadium finale in Week 17, they’ll grow to be the primary crew in NFL historical past to lose 9 dwelling video games in a single season.
The season from hell can also be punctuated with one other embarrassment: Barkley breaking the NFL’s all-time single-season dashing report towards the very crew that drafted him.
Sprinkled in is the bungled launch of quarterback Daniel Jones, ongoing fan protests that intention to embarrass possession, a league-worst offense now being led by road free agent Tim Boyle, and seemingly limitless mockery from the nationwide media.
In just some quick weeks, co-owners John Mara and Steve Tisch must make a tricky choice: Burn all of it down and reset once more, or danger a fan revolt by working it again with the present regime.
These may be the one selections as a result of a half measure won’t suffice. The Giants can’t afford to fireplace both normal supervisor Joe Schoen or head coach Brian Daboll, forcing a possible alternative to inherit the opposite.
The explanations to fireplace Schoen are ample, as Bobby Skinner of Talkin’ Giants lately laid out. His 2024 draft class shouldn’t be a saving grace, particularly contemplating his failures within the earlier two drafts have led the Giants so far.
Daboll is equally at fault for the crew’s failures. His incapability to handle relationships with coordinators and assistants is alarming, his game-day roster administration has straight contributed to 2 losses, and his play-calling has led to a points-per-game regression in comparison with Mike Kafka a season in the past.
It’s virtually like Daboll has gone from Bono to Bozo.
There are few, if any redeeming qualities in regards to the 2024 iteration of the New York Giants. And every week, they one way or the other discover a new, humiliating low. Issues have gotten so unhealthy that debate has stirred over this crew in comparison with the 2021 model headed by Dave Gettleman and Joe Choose.
Who had that on their Bingo card?
However that’s additionally why possession has to tear the Band-Help utterly off or depart it on for another season. A half measure would merely kick the can down the highway and proceed the post-Tom Coughlin cycle that has gotten them right here within the first place.
In the event that they had been to maintain Schoen and hearth Daboll and the final supervisor whiffed in one other draft, the Giants would wish to usher in a brand new GM who would then probably hearth the lame-duck head coach and inherit no matter quarterback Schoen finally selects within the 2025 NFL draft. We’ve seen how that story performs out.
In the event that they went the opposite approach and fired Schoen and stored Daboll, it might drive the incoming GM to inherit a head coach he didn’t rent. That’s not a recipe for achievement, particularly whenever you throw within the upcoming quarterback choice.
The most effective choice for the franchise can be to half methods with Schoen and Daboll, rent a veteran government with a robust resume as normal supervisor, permit them to select the top coach, after which go after their very own quarterback of the longer term. A real clear slate.
But when Mara and Tisch are decided to indicate persistence, then they should be all the way in which in. Preserve the present regime intact, permit them to draft a quarterback come April, and hope that all of it works out and also you don’t end up on this very same scenario a 12 months from now.
