Final week, I mentioned the NFL gamers rating Miami Dolphins huge receiver Tyreek Hill because the primary participant in all the league. I could not assist however marvel if the Phins fan base noticed it the identical means. I knew that as a lot as I like what Hill brings to the Dolphins, which is nothing wanting making the offense go at occasions, I doubt I would choose him first general if I have been constructing a workforce from scratch, however that may be a unique argument. I then requested the next query:
Do you assume Tyreek Hill is the most effective general participant within the NFL, and in that case, why? If not, who do you may have in that high spot, and the place would Tyreek fall below that individual?
Beneath are a few of your solutions and ideas on the query of the day-
SuperG! appears to recommend that Mahomes may be the primary man, I believe.
Properly, Mahomes has already been MVP, voted no 1 within the NFL High 100 and has 3 SB rings. So actually, which one is best?
Spok507 is just not one to argue with principally big human beings.
Far be it for me to disagree with the NFL gamers who voted, so sure, Hill is #1. He’s a participant who modifications the sport and makes defenses at all times account for him. I nonetheless imagine that’s why they went after him and Waddle in that Titans sport so laborious final season — with the intention of taking them out. Cease Hill and also you stage the enjoying area towards the Fins. Cease Waddle as properly and also you cease the offense chilly. However sure, Hill deserves #1. He give his all each time he steps on the sector, doesn’t take performs off and forces defenders to take care of him even when he’s not the main focus. Very glad he’s a Dolphin. I’ve no drawback with him being voted #1 over Jackson and Mahomes. Bored with QBs getting all of the reward, particularly when it’s a workforce sport. They contact the ball each play, however they want the remainder of the workforce to make issues occur, and Hill does that in spades.
SlayerNation1 says Mahomes is just not the most effective, not less than final season.
As a degree of order, Mahomes was handed over as #1 twice final season, by two totally different factions:
-the gamers selected Hill
-the MVP voters selected Lamar
Mahomes is nice, the Protection gained them the championship final season. That’s what the voting displays.
The most effective participant for a specific season doesn’t at all times win all of it. Mahomes, was not the most effective participant final season.
VolFaninFla says he’s a high 5 wideout, however past that, nah…
He’s undoubtedly a high 5 WR however “not” the #1 participant within the league.
Grmtfinfan says Mahomes is his man, , given a selection.
I’d take Mahomes over Hill. I don’t care concerning the stats of the common season. I need a participant that elevates his sport towards the most effective groups and within the playoffs. Hill disappeared towards each. Don’t get me mistaken Hill is a good participant and one to construct a workforce round however IMO I’d take Mahomes first. He has achieved extra with much less expertise round him.
glen55 says yeah, perhaps?
I don’t assume there’s a clear-cut #1, however Hill deserves it as a lot as anyone and he performs a premium place, so it’s laborious to argue with the score.
daytonadolfan says he nonetheless must validate his ticket to the Tremendous Bowl for the Dolphins! Appropriate!
I’d say he’s the #1 participant within the NFL, He now must validate that and lead us to the Tremendous bowl and past ! Oh and take a look at to not get tackled so laborious this 12 months , we’d like you to go all out , all season !
SlayerNation1 was working extra time, giving us two solutions, and thinks that timing has lots to do with who’s voted the place. Good level!
Sure it’s reputable. Mahomes Is the most effective QB. KC has been capable of win the final 2 SBs due to Tyreek’s greatness as a lot as Mahomes’.
Tyreek was already nice, which is how KC obtained a lot draft capital. KC used it correctly on good Defensive items which made sufficient performs to eke out 2 SBs, extra energy to them.
What no one noticed coming was Tyreek going subsequent stage in Miami. That’s the reason all of the speaking heads are crying… all of them predicted Tyreek changing into irrelevant with Tua.
Additionally, why can’t individuals wrap their heads across the timing of the voting? Tyreek was on a report tempo in November and Mahomes was nonetheless attempting to determine the best way to rating factors within the second half of video games.
DolphinFan85 likes to comply with the greats when they’re on the sector. Let’s hope that Hill creates far much less information after retirement than the opposite two gamers talked about.
Similar to OJ Simpson and LT my eyes comply with him when he’s on a soccer area.Appears a stage above different gamers on the sector.A terrific face of the workforce for the Dolphins and a participant who defines fashionable soccer in 24.
darrel.owen appropriately factors out how Hill may be essentially the most harmful participant within the NFL.
Hill is a game-changer. DCs MUST account for him on each play. He’s one contact away from a landing on any given play and may take unusual passes the space. He makes everybody round him higher. Is he higher than Mahomes? Would I relatively have Hill or Mahomes? I believe that’s a tricky name. I do know there’s no different participant apart from Mahomes that I’d contemplate pretty much as good as Hill. Let’s simply say that I’m actually glad Hill is a Dolphin.
Dolfanjoe says Hill stands alone on the high of the NFL mountain.
Hill is an outstanding athlete. Mahomes is the most effective QB on the market by far and a terrific athlete additionally, however not in Hill’s class. # 1 receiver for my part, and almost definitely may have performed many positions and achieved one hell of a job at it ! You do should put a participant along with his expertise on the high. lets hope Tua makes him and the others shine this 12 months ! I for one am trying on the probability that our operating backs outshine the receiving corp. This may be one hell of a victory for us !
The consensus appears to be that the consideration of finest general participant within the NFL is deserved by Hill. He definitely takes this Miami Dolphins workforce to a different stage. Thanks to every of you who learn the query of the day and answered the query. I apologize that there was no put up final night. I used to be out of city attempting to get again residence and falsely believed that I’d be again in time to write down a put up.
