Geno Smith, NFL’s 18th greatest quarterback? PFF analyst explains reasoning

Professional Soccer Focus lately launched its rankings of the highest (projected) beginning quarterbacks within the NFL forward of the 2024 season. The quarterbacks are separated into tiers, of which one is devoted completely to Patrick Mahomes.

Geno Smith is in Tier 4, which is described as “The Melting Pot of Starters.” I’d argue these are typically the quarterbacks who considerably divide opinion to some extent. Alongside Smith are Jordan Love, Brock Purdy, Tua Tagovailoa, Kirk Cousins, Jared Goff, Kyler Murray, and Caleb Williams. Geno is available in at No. 18 (solely forward of Williams in his tier).

Right here’s the PFF blurb:

Smith put collectively back-to-back very stable seasons in 2022 and 2023. In his most up-to-date marketing campaign, he elevated his big-time throw charge from 5.4% to six.0% and decreased his turnover-worthy play proportion from 4.2% to three.5%. He missed two video games as a result of a groin harm in 2023, so a few of these cumulative numbers may have been even higher.

However Smith’s two years have been a story of 4 quarters. Within the first half of 2022, he earned the third-highest passing grade within the league. Within the second half, he led the league in turnover-worthy performs. Within the first half of 2023, he had extra turnover-worthy performs (13) than big-time throws (11). However from Week 10 on, he was prime 5 in passing grade and big-time throws.

At 33 years previous and coming into the ultimate yr of his cope with assured cash, Smith is probably not seen as a franchise quarterback. However he’s completely the sort of man who can engineer a win in any given week.

Trevor Sikkema defined his reasoning to hosts Michael Bumpus and Stacy Jo Rost on Seattle Sports activities 710.

“Truthfully, after I had him at 18, it felt low for the highs that I’ve seen in Geno,” Sikkema stated Wednesday on Seattle Sports activities’ Bump and Stacy. “However it was simply the up and down … for the final two years that was sort of powerful for him. I consider he’s a extremely good quarterback. It’s simply sort of a consistency factor. However we’ve seen it from him, for certain.”

[…]

“He’s had these streaks over the past couple of years and also you’ve simply gotta all put it collectively,” Sikkema stated. “Him being wholesome, the fellows round him being wholesome, having that consistency, attending to play a ton collectively, that chemistry. I believe that it’s all there for Geno.”

It’s arduous to disagree with the concept Geno has had some main peaks and valleys as a Seahawks starter. The new begin to 2022 gave option to a little bit of a cooldown towards the top of the season, and his robust end to 2023 (beginning with the 41-35 loss to the Dallas Cowboys) was preceded by up-and-down performances. There have been undoubtedly some extenuating circumstances concerning accidents (together with to himself final season) that factored in, however the outcomes are the outcomes.

I do know that he fared lots higher below stress than the attention take a look at could point out.

Hopefully with a brand new offensive coordinator and a greater offensive line, we are able to see extra of one of the best of Geno than his lowlights in 2024… or perhaps you assume it doesn’t matter the OL or OC, the No. 18 rating is basically who he’s. Vote within the ballot beneath!